Paul could have avoided this by not joining the Fremen in the first book.

I've just finished reading it, so please no spoilers beyond :)Īt the time of Dune Messiah, the empire is already a theocratic tyranny. I'm not sure that I'm articulating this well, but I'm curious what others think. He continually attempts to hide his fallibility from the general populace, and Stilgar conspires with him to maintain this deception.īut why? Did he see that the futures in which he refuted the idea of him as messiah were worse? Or did he not see them at all? Was he so afraid to divert himself from his envisioned futures that he only chose amongst relative certainties? I believe it's Scytale who says (paraphrasing), 'A man will die rather than deny his own nature.' I took this to mean that Paul will choose death over relinquishing his role as Messiah. He continues to act in accord with the image of himself as Muad'dib, a god among men. Paul is trying to navigate the visions of the future he perceives.

Bans will be issued at moderator discretion.Ĭould Paul have prevented his regime from becoming tyrannical, bureaucratic, and amoral if he had been willing to present himself as fallible?.

Indicate the scope of your spoiler by changing the 'Spoiler Scope' to something that best indicates what your spoiler is about, like a book or film title.

Here's an example: **Spoiler Scope** >!Spoilery Text!< will show up as Spoiler Scope Spoilery Text in post bodies and comments. Be sure not to put any space between the text you want to hide and the beginning and end spoiler tags.

The new spoiler functionality now works pretty much everywhere, as long as it's followed correctly.

Comment spoiler code does not work in post titles. See Reddit's spoiler functionality for posts. Feel free to share your memes at r/dunememes or on the discord. Ask yourself 'Will this promote good discussion?' If the answer is no, prepare to have your post removed. Low effort posts will be subject to removal.Be excellent to each other, and practice good reddiquette.Please flair your posts, but remember that flairs aren't spoiler tags, they're only meant to denote the scope of your discussion.

If you see un-tagged spoilers do not hesitate to hit 'report'. (See Spoiler Guidelines below) Exceptions being in threads where the scope of discussion is clear. Tag your spoilers! - Always tag your spoilers.Widely considered one of the greatest works within the sci-figenre, Dune has been the subject of various film and TV adaptations, including a major motion picture released in 2021. Dune is a landmark science fiction novel first published in 1965 and the first in a 6-book saga penned by author Frank Herbert.

Dune messiah paul